Abstract
This exploratory study investigates factors and consequences of underdiagnoses or late diagnoses of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in females favoring males in the referral, diagnosis, and treatment processes resulting in gender disparities. A literature review in PubMed, PsychINFO, PsychArticles, and PsychiatryOnline from 2010 to 2023 underscores significant implications of delayed ADHD diagnosis in females, hindering timely access, support, and interventions during critical developmental years. Factors associated with underdiagnosis of ADHD among girls include gender differences in symptomology presentation, comorbidity, and gender bias among parents, teachers, and healthcare providers. We highlight the role of ethnicity and cultural factors. This bias prevents girls from receiving necessary ADHD support and treatment, impacting their health, social, and economic outcomes into adulthood. We summarize strategies to urgently address gaps in ADHD research and practice. Raising awareness among communities, healthcare providers, educators, and parents is vital to alleviate these gender disparities. By illuminating factors contributing to delayed diagnoses, the study informs policymakers and stakeholders, facilitating targeted interventions to improve early detection and treatment outcomes for females with ADHD.
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2024
Almekhlafi Kayla, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Introduction
In 2020, approximately 6.8% or 366 million adults globally had symptomatic attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and 2.6% or 140 million had persistent adult ADHD which began in childhood How ADHD presents differently over the lifespan, by gender, race/ethnicity and symptomatology is an ongoing area of inquiry One of the key factors associated with the underdiagnosis of ADHD among girls is symptom presentation differences. A review found that 3.10% of the adult population had inattentive ADHD, followed by hyperactive (2.95%) and combined (2.44%) Comorbid conditions have also shown to contribute to the underdiagnosis of ADHD in females. A common occurrence of the inattentive subtype in female ADHD diagnoses is often accompanied by concurrent internalizing disorders like anxiety and depression. More than 53.5% of females and 48.5% males with ADHD had one or more of the six psychiatric comorbidities, compared to 13.7% of women and 9.1% of men in the remaining population It is not only types of symptoms that differ by gender, but also severity of symptoms. ADHD symptoms diagnosed tend to be more severe among boys than girls. In a study with 153 (64%) children met the diagnostic criteria for ADHD per DSM-5 guidelines, 79% were boys and 21% girls, with a 3.8:1 male-to-female ratio. Within the high-symptom group of 130 children, 62% were male and 38% were female There are also biological differences between male and female children diagnosed with ADHD. A study showed that sex differences in frontal white matter microstructure may contribute to neurocognitive outcomes in children with ADHD. They concluded that boys with ADHD present greater abnormalities in frontal motor regions Some studies have shown differences in parental referral for boys vs. girls There is sufficient evidence to conclude gender bias among mental health and medical providers, in terms of assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of ADHD differentially by gender It is important to highlight that girls and women within specific cultures have even lower odds of being referred, let alone diagnosed, and receive appropriate treatment. Research shows that ethnic minority children are less likely to be recognized and treated for ADHD than their non-minority counterparts This could explain why some cultures have lower rates of a mental illness as they may not consider certain behaviors atypical. Minority adults are less likely to be diagnosed than non-minority adults One study found white children were more likely to receive ADHD treatment, with Asian children having the lowest odds of receiving any treatment by 64% The relationship between ADHD and culture is not well established, with differing opinions in ADHD prevalence, and differences potentially resulting from differential tolerance of hyperactive behavior across cultures Next, we summarize the multidimensional impacts of ADHD on girls and women. Underdiagnosed ADHD among girls during childhood and adolescent years has shown to have significant social-emotional, behavioral, academic short and long-term impacts. A recent study by Young et al (2020) found that undiagnosed girls had a higher risk of academic underachievement compared to their peers. They found that girls with ADHD symptoms, but no diagnosis were significantly more likely to experience difficulties with organization, time management, and completing schoolwork. Many girls with ADHD experience social and emotional difficulties. Another study found increased risk of self-injury and suicide attempts and social difficulties among girls with ADHD undiagnosed Numerous studies have shown adverse outcomes of ADHD, diagnosed and undiagnosed, on women and mothers during adulthood years. Research indicates that mothers with ADHD are at an increased risk of experiencing birth complications and adverse reproductive outcomes, risk-taking behaviors, maternal mental health issues, and challenging parenting practices. A study found that ADHD was related to higher levels of stress, depressive symptoms, lower social support from significant others, and unwanted pregnancies The association between maternal ADHD and mental health issues and disorders is well- established. Bartelt, Piff, Vitek, & Barkley (2023) reported a 24% higher prevalence of postpartum depression among mothers with underdiagnosed ADHD. Murray et al. (2022) found elevated levels of stress and depressive symptoms among mothers with ADHD. Comorbidities significantly amplify the burden of ADHD on maternal health. Research has consistently shown challenges parents with ADHD face when managing their children's behavior and emotional needs. Furthermore, The social challenges faced by individuals with ADHD extend to maternal roles, impacting interpersonal relationships and social functioning. The economic burden of ADHD on affected individuals and society at large is substantial. In summary, ADHD in women not only affects their own health and well-being but also has far-reaching consequences for their children, families, and society as a whole, underscoring the importance of early diagnosis, intervention, and support. The evidence presented underscores the significant and multifaceted impact of ADHD on mothers, encompassing physical health, mental well-being, parenting dynamics, social relationships, and economic stability. Addressing the complex interplay of ADHD symptoms, comorbidities, and social-economic factors requires a comprehensive and integrated approach that incorporates targeted interventions, support services, and policy initiatives. By recognizing and addressing the challenges faced by mothers with ADHD, it becomes possible to enhance their well-being, improve family functioning, and mitigate the broader societal impacts of the condition. Gender bias in ADHD referrals and diagnosis, presentation symptomology differences, and cultural or socialization differences by gender need to be recognized and addressed using multi-pronged strategies. We need more training and education on differential presentation of ADHD among girls vs. boys, a clear criterion for referrals, including a reassessment of behaviors warranting consideration for ADHD referrals. All parents, especially those with girls need to learn about ADHD symptomatology, and comorbidity. They need to advocate with providers for thorough assessment of symptoms and proper diagnosis and subsequent treatment. It could save years of mental health, social, and academic consequences. Primary care providers, including pediatricians and nurse practitioners, play a crucial role in diagnosing ADHD and should receive adequate training to recognize symptoms in females (CHADD, n.d.). We need more training for healthcare professionals on ADHD symptom presentation in both young girls and adult females. This includes awareness education and updated diagnostic criteria for girls and females in various healthcare settings, such as obstetrics/gynecology, pediatrics, midwifery, nursing, general practice, and mental health. A consensus meeting in the United Kingdom of healthcare professionals who specialize in the care of girls and adult females with ADHD, recently discussed symptom presentation, criteria for referral, assessment protocols, treatment modalities, and the establishment of collaborative efforts among multiple agencies to ensure comprehensive care for females with ADHD. The experts underscored the importance of abandoning outdated biases and clinician predispositions within the realm of mental health diagnosis for ADHD They emphasized that clinicians should refrain from exclusively seeking the stereotypical disruptive behavioral components of ADHD and instead, incorporate an understanding of the internalized presentation commonly observed in female patients. This approach is crucial for supporting a more nuanced and developmentally challenging manifestation of ADHD in females Addressing bias within the healthcare sector, particularly within the realm of mental health, is a matter of paramount importance. Gender bias, whether overt or unconscious, permeates various facets of healthcare. Research has illuminated the existence of unconscious biases among physicians It is imperative to provide teachers and school counselors with appropriate up-to-date information on ADHD and its prevalence differences in males and females to discern the prevalent symptoms of ADHD in girls. This is essential to discern prevalent symptoms of ADHD in girls, thereby mitigating the potential over-referral of male students and the inadvertent oversight of ADHD symptoms in female counterparts. Symptoms such as inattentiveness, depression, anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and perfectionist behavior can hide ADHD symptoms and delay diagnosis, impacting outcomes in adulthood, including socio-economic status, pregnancy, and motherhood The primary intervention for mothers would be to include some mental health assessment, perhaps by collaborating or partnering with mental health clinicians, or integrating assessment of ADHD and other mental health comorbidity conditions during prenatal and postnatal care visits. Current postnatal care typically focuses on the child, with limited attention to maternal mental health beyond postpartum depression, and mothers receiving care the first six weeks post childbirth In conclusion, addressing gender bias, enhancing professional training and awareness, educating teachers and school counselors, and integrating ADHD monitoring into prenatal and postnatal care are essential steps to mitigate underdiagnosis of ADHD in adult females. By implementing these strategies, we can improve outcomes for females struggling with undiagnosed or underdiagnosed ADHD and promote their overall well-being across the lifespan. Prompt identification and diagnosis in the early stages can enhance the quality of life for females, leading to improvements in education, economic prospects, social and family relationships, as well as fostering heightened self-awareness and self-esteem. Thus, it is vital to have comprehensive validated assessment tools that incorporate common female phenotypes and work well with high accuracy and precision in female cases. The spectrum of ADHD symptoms is inherently diverse, yet the available body of research and literature often falls short in elucidating this complexity to clinicians. Clinical practice has predominantly centered around recognizing the overt and hyperactive manifestations of ADHD, which are more readily observable in males and a specific subset of females who exhibit pronounced external symptoms. Conversely, there remains a notable shortage of research focusing on internalized ADHD symptoms and the expansive breadth of ADHD's clinical presentation. This knowledge gap underscores the need for a more comprehensive understanding of ADHD's multifaceted nature amongst healthcare professionals. Addressing gender bias within the realms of mental health, particularly among diagnosing clinicians, should entail a fundamental paradigm shift from solely evaluating overt externalizing behaviors to a holistic assessment of individuals' lifelong functional impairments. To achieve a more equitable diagnostic framework, it is recommended to incorporate the operationalization of emotional dysregulation, internalizing symptomatology, as well as indicators of trauma and self-harm, alongside traditional behavioral criteria. This approach holds the potential to enhance diagnostic accuracy and facilitate the transition from subthreshold conditions to formal diagnosis There are various assessment tools for screening of ADHD in children and adults. However, there are currently no gender-specific assessment tools for ADHD. Assessment tools like the Behavior Assessment System for Children -3 (BASC-3) and the Conners Comprehensive Behavior Rating Scales for children (CBRS) involve parent and teacher rating forms, with some including self-reports. Assessment tools for adults like the Adult ADHD Self-report Scale (ASRS) involving self reports, and the Conners Adult ADHD Rating Scales (CAARS) involving self-report, observations, and interviews are common tools used to screen for adult ADHD. With no existing gender-specific ADHD assessment tools coupled with existing bias among teachers, parents, and clinicians, this underscores the significance of abandoning a one-size-fits-all diagnostic approach and implementing more gender-specific criteria in the evaluation of ADHD in girls and women. This review was limited by lack of data from healthcare professionals, as ADHD is not seen as a primary mental health disorder for females, and thus diagnostic information and symptoms are not recorded in patients’ medical records to access for research studies. Second, patients may not be willing to participate as they have not been diagnosed with ADHD or do not want to acknowledge mental health symptoms, that is associated stigma. Third, clinicians may have limited time and capacity to accurately assess ADHD symptoms. Limited access or quality of healthcare, particularly among low-income minorities, would limit the data available as more females with ADHD are unreported. This review increases awareness of ADHD prevalence in females and the factors associated with undiagnosed cases in females. It also highlights the tendency to overlook ADHD in girls during childhood, resulting in a rise in undiagnosed adult females with ADHD symptoms. This study also brings special attention to the negative effects of undiagnosed ADHD among mothers. The results show that there is a common misconception that ADHD is a male centered mental health disorder. Public health professionals can enhance their awareness of the presence of ADHD in females, recognize the diversity in gender differences in symptomatology, address gender bias and gender and racial disparities, and promote education for clinicians on female ADHD for earlier and more effective diagnosis. Anticipated results show that ADHD is drastically under-detected in females. We anticipate an increase in ADHD diagnosis in females which may be accompanied by a decrease or similar results in postpartum depression. This is due to symptoms commonly associated with postpartum depression that may be related to females trying to cope with undiagnosed ADHD symptoms as well as the beginning of motherhood and the effects of comorbidity with ADHD. The anticipated increase in ADHD diagnosis rates should be met with resources for females, including mothers with ADHD. These resources may include referrals to healthcare providers who can prescribe medication, referrals to psychological counseling, and support groups which can provide necessary social support, and education about what ADHD is and coping mechanisms We conclude that females are commonly under-referred, underdiagnosed, and undertreated with ADHD, resulting in significant health, social, and economic impacts. The findings call for much greater effort and investments to educate and train teachers, parents, and healthcare and mental health providers in different realms to be more sensitive and vigilant in screening for and diagnosing ADHD among females. Greater investments, training, research, and systems need to be in place. Funding this research would provide the development of necessary education and training for healthcare providers, resulting in better outcomes in females with ADHD.