Abstract
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2023
Maru Temesgen Minwuyelet, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Introduction
There are many different types of liver diseases and conditions that affect liver function. These can be acute liver failure, which results in a rapid loss of liver function usually within days or weeks, and chronic liver disease, which is characterized by a gradual deterioration of liver functions which could progress to cirrhosis or to hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) Alcohol-related liver disease accounts for 9.5% of CLD worldwide, with rates varying by region, with Europe having the highest rates Every year, approximately 2 million CLD deaths occur as a result of cirrhosis, viral hepatitis, and HCC complications and the prevalence of cirrhosis ranged 4.5% to 9.5% The global trend showed epidemiology shift of CLD, an increasing metabolic and alcoholic liver disease, and a decreasing hepatitis viruses In Ethiopia, CLD was the 7th leading cause of death in 2019 and according to studies the three most common etiologies were Hepatitis B virus, alcohol, and hepatitis C virus with a prevalence of 40%, 17% and 15% respectively which showed variation by gender and age
Results
A total of 89 medical records of liver patients were observed of which the majority 59 (66.3%) were males and 66 (74.2%) rural residents. The median age was 35 years ranged 4 to 85 (SD± 15.7) and about half (48.3%) were below 35 years age ( The most common clinical presentation was ascites which accounted 68.5% followed by jaundice (19.1%). The mean duration of clinical sign was 6.5 months with minimum of 1 a maximum of 36 months. Hypertension was seen as frequently observed comorbidity at proportion of 11.2% followed by diabetes and tuberculosis at 4.5%. Twenty seven study participants (30.3%) were anemic and 21 (23.6%) had history of taking drug for long time ( Chronic hepatitis B infection was the most frequent etiology of CLD at 32.6% followed by Alcoholic liver disease and Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease at 21.3% and 18% respectively. In sixteen (18%) study subjects, unexplained cause of CLD was seen with 21 (23.6%) subjects with long time drug intake was identified most frequently for hypertension (11.2%), and diabetes (4.5%). Majority of CLD cases are males 59 (66.3%) and the most frequent etiology in males is chronic hepatitis B infection and alcoholic liver disease whereas, non-alcoholic liver disease and hepatitis B virus cause are the main etiology in females. As indicated in In our study, aspartate transaminase (AST) and alanine transaminase (ALT) enzyme measurement was detected in 69 study subjects and increased level was observed for AST in 32 (46.3%) and for ALT in 19 subjects (27.5%) and for both in 17 (24.6%) based on ALT and AST reference limit of 0-42U/L and 0-37 U/L currently used in the country respectively. High level of AST than ALT which is mostly related to cirrhosis was observed in 49 (71.0%) study participants. As shown in the graph below, the five year trend of CLD types in the study area exhibit variation in proportion and rate of increment (
Male
59
66.3
Female
30
33.7
Rural
66
74.2
Urban
23
25.8
<18 years
5
5.6
18 – 24 years
8
9
25 – 34 Years
30
33.7
35 – 44 Years
15
16.9
45 – 54 years
12
13.5
>55 years
19
21.3
89
100
Clinical presentation
Ascites
61
68.5
Jaundice
17
19.1
Bloody vomit
9
10.1
Mental sign
1
1.1
Other
1
1.1
Alcoholic Liver Disease
19
21.3
Nonalcoholic Faty Liver Disease
16
18
Chronic Hepatitis B infection
29
32.6
Chronic Hepatitis C infection
3
3.4
Hepatosplinic schistosomiasis
6
6.7
Unexplained
16
18
No
68
76.4
Diabetes
4
4.5
Hypertension
10
11.2
Tuberculosis
4
4.5
Diabetes and Hypertension
1
1.1
Other
1
2.2
Yes
27
30.3
No
62
69.7
Yes
21
23.6
No
68
76.4
Male
14
6
22
3
4
10
59 (66.3%)
Female
5
10
7
0
2
6
30 (33.7%)
Below 18
0
0
2
0
1
2
5 (5.6%)
19-24
0
0
7
0
1
0
8 (9.0%)
25-34
2
4
10
2
3
9
30 (33.7%)
35-44
4
5
3
1
1
1
15 (16.9%)
45-54
4
1
5
0
0
2
12 (13.5%)
55 and above
9
6
2
0
0
2
19 (21.3%)
Urban
4
4
10
0
0
5
23 (25.8%)
Rural
15
12
19
3
6
11
66 (74.2%)
19
16
29
3
6
16
89 (100%)
Discussion
Chronic liver disease is believed to be distributed in different population groups and geographic area and this retrospective hospital based study was done to determine the five year magnitude and trends of chronic liver disease and describes the different types of CLD. In our finding, it was noted that CLD was most frequently distributed among males, age group below 35 years and rural residents. A study from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia also reported high prevalence of CLD in males than females. However, it contrasts to the Addis Ababa finding that showed the most commonly affected age group of 31 to 50 years The most frequent etiology of CLD in the present study was chronic hepatitis B infection (32.6%), Alcoholic liver disease (21.35) and Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (18%). This finding reveals hepatitis B infection remains the leading cause of CLD in Ethiopia similar to previous reports in Sub-Sahara Africa at 34%. Likewise, alcohol is the second cause of CLD which contributed slightly higher than previous 18% of CLD in Sub Sahara Africa. On the other hand, the proportion of NAFLD in this study is higher than the previous report of 12% in Ethiopia This study found that, NAFLD and hepatitis B are the most common causes of chronic liver disease in females at 33.3% (10 out of 30) and 23.3% (7 out of 30) respectively unlike in males where hepatitis B and alcohol are the most common etiologies of CLD at 37.3% (22 out of 59) and 10.1% (6 out of 59) respectively. This shows sign of epidemiology change to NAFLD in the adult population similar to the global trend Ascites is the main signs of liver cirrhosis resulted from portal hypertension and it is the most frequently seen clinical presentation in the present study at 68.5% which higher than previous report of 46.2% from Gondar, Ethiopia Aminotransferase enzymes, aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT), are commonly associated with liver disease as both enzymes are highly concentrated in the liver. However, as AST is also spread to the heart, skeletal muscle, kidneys, brain and red blood cells, an increase in ALT is more specific for liver damage including sign of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease Increasing five year trend of all forms of CLD is also observed in this study with hepatitis infection remaining the highest and still showed increasing trend. On top of this nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and unexplained causes of chronic liver disease are linearly increasing which reveals the importance of addressing metabolic disorders and improving the diagnosis of liver disease.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this study showed the most frequent etiology of CLD in the study area is hepatitis B infection, Alcohol and Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. The proportion of NAFLD and unexplained causes of CLD are higher than the previous reports and increasing five year trend of all forms of CLD is also observed. In this finding chronic liver disease is most frequently distributed among males, age group below 35 years and rural residents. Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and hepatitis B are the most common causes of chronic liver disease in females whereas, hepatitis B infection is the major causative factor chronic liver disease in the age group 19-24 years and current interventions should consider this population groups. About two third of chronic liver patients in the study area were in the advanced cirrhotic stage indicated by ascites and AST to ALT ratio of greater than one which reveals delay in diagnosis suggesting the need of early screening.