Journal of Aging Research And Healthcare

Journal of Aging Research And Healthcare

Current Issue Volume No: 5 Issue No: 1

Review-article Article Open Access
  • Available online freely Peer Reviewed
  • Osteoarthritis In Older Adults: Is More Emphasis On Managing And Mitigating Its Stressful Ramifications, And Enhancing Coping, And Self Efficacy Cognitions Indicated?

    Marks Ray 1
       

    1 Department of Research, Osteoarthritis Research Center, Box 5B, Thornhill, ONT L3T 5H3, Canada 

    Abstract

    Efforts to mitigate or prevent painful disabling osteoarthritis have been pursued for more than a century with limited success. This current overview briefly summarizes how selected beliefs and behaviors, including coping and stress management approaches are potential mediators or moderators of osteoarthritis pain and its overall common adverse prognosis and outcome. Published data housed predominantly in PUBMED, PUBMED CENTRAL, SCIENCE DIRECT, and GOOGLE SCHOLAR sites and pertaining to selected aspects of the literature of current interest, cumulative results reported as of May 30, 2024, show a modest to strong rationale exists for considering the abovementioned factors in efforts to reduce pain and enable daily functions. Accordingly this line of research should be continued, and translated clinically without undue delay, especially in the face of increases in the aging population and osteoarthritis prevalence and undue suffering.

    Author Contributions
    Received May 31, 2024     Accepted Jun 04, 2024     Published Jun 10, 2024

    Copyright© 2024 Marks Ray.
    License
    Creative Commons License   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

    Competing interests

    The authors declare no conflict of interest.

    Funding Interests:

    Citation:

    Marks Ray (2024) Osteoarthritis In Older Adults: Is More Emphasis On Managing And Mitigating Its Stressful Ramifications, And Enhancing Coping, And Self Efficacy Cognitions Indicated? Journal of Aging Research And Healthcare. - 5(1):17-31
    DOI 10.14302/issn.2474-7785.jarh-24-5141

    Introduction

    Introduction

    Osteoarthritis, a prevalent form of arthritis and a clinical syndrome affecting a substantive proportion of older adults in all parts of the world is frequently accompanied by unrelenting often times debilitating episodes of intractable pain, ‘low grade’ inflammation, declining functional and self-care-related abilities, plus life quality. As well as its predominant physical manifestations that include stiffness, joint laxity and instability, plus poor physical endurance, multiple psychological symptoms that are commonly observed to emerge over time may well impact the extent of any prevailing physiological disease correlates and its progression, as well as outcome expectations, and confidence or self efficacy for managing the disease. Additional disabling features include but are not limited to fears of movement and injury, sleep disturbances, heightened degrees of worry and pain sensitivity, fatigue and possible depression. Moreover, there may be a gradual decline in health perceptions, motivation to help oneself, poor treatment adherence, self imposed limitations in activity, and decreases in coping ability and efficacy 123. Although deemed to occur with age, this pattern of declining physical prowess and increasing dysfunction is not consistently observed however, suggesting some degree of variability does exist that may be remediable. For example, while often deemed ‘incurable’ with few universally efficacious treatment options, adopting a view that osteoarthritis as a health syndrome is potentially amenable to some degree of mitigation through the adoption of a variety self management approaches may indeed have implications for possibly reducing its immense personal and societal costs 34.

    At present, the options for advancing non-surgical non medicinal self-regulatory, self-management practices and strategies aimed at helping the supplicant to remain as active and productive as possible are largely reliant on exercise, weight reduction, and joint protection. Unfortunately, these widespread recommendations are often not followed consistently, possibly due to the presence of persistent pain, plus potentially erroneous disease and pain beliefs and others that focus on a perceived personal incapacity to control pain, fears of movement, and a belief intervention is futile. In addition, the presence of a depressed mood state may impact the desire or motivation to act, as may pervasive feelings of helplessness and hopelessness 6.

    In particular, ample research indicates that in cases where there is an emergent intrinsically perceived low sense of personal self-efficacy for overcoming osteoarthritis challenges, plus overwhelming feelings of doom, doubts or uncertainty about one’s coping ability, as well as uncertainty about recommendations and their efficacy, successful outcomes are less likely than not. Moreover a parallel adoption or perpetuation of an ‘unhealthy’ sedentary lifestyle and poor nutrition coupled with a failure to protect against joint as well as emotional stresses may be expected to further interact with the underlying condition to engender a cycle of pervasive joint destruction, feelings of unabated distress, anxiety, fear, frustration, and depression, plus pain and sleep challenges that may not be commonly addressed by standard therapies 378910, but can undoubtedly interfere with what can be done to mitigate this disease in the older adult population effectively and significantly.

    Given the immense persistent social and personal costs of osteoarthritis and that little progress has been made in more than a century to advance basic day to day osteoarthritis management and a life of promise, rather than dysfunction, we elected to focus on the what is currently observed in this regard with respect to the broad topic of stress, coping and coping efficacy, and coping methods and their relevance to secondary and tertiary disability prevention, factors not well studied or highlighted in most practice realms.

    The rationale for this stems from the 2010 report by Benyon et al. 11 that coping strategies and self-efficacy are important prognostic factors for people with osteoarthritis that may be amenable to modification. This idea is indeed consistent with the well reported observation that radiographic osteoarthritis and pain are not directly correlated in many cases and surgery to replace the diseased joint does not always yield desired functional outcomes. It is also consistent with the importance of achieving a non stressful rather than stressful state of being as regards overall health and life quality and evidence of considerable stress factors affecting older adults with osteoarthritis 12. Another related health determinant known as self-efficacy, and describing a person’s belief about his or her ability to successfully organize and implement a specific behavior or cease an unhealthy one, which can range from low to high is a significant mediator of multiple chronic illnesses such as osteoarthritis where behaviors are strong disease explanatory and mediating factors.

    Specific Aim

    As per Benyon et al. 11, this updated brief overview highlights the need for further research to ascertain the predictive value of coping on osteoarthritis wellbeing as well as what coping strategies are recommended even if less well investigated than other realms of practice. It also highlights pertinent aspects of the importance of assessing and maximizing self-efficacy perceptions, especially in relation to excess pain perceptions 813 as well as coping efficacy 1415, pain being the most common sought after symptom experienced by osteoarthritis sufferers.

    Based on the principles of self efficacy and as outlined by DiRenzo and Finan 14 it aimed to uncover if indeed the adoption of selected behavioral and cognitive strategies or avoidance of negative behaviors and thoughts do justify their usage in older adults with painful osteoarthritis, mood disturbances, and possible declining participation in physical and social realms. Whether. improvements in self-efficacy and coping skills and capacity are associated with improvements in patient-reported outcomes and can be altered to reduce pain, fears, threats of disability and improve functioning, for example in those exhibiting neuropathic pain was specifically sought 141516.

    Discussion

    Discussion

    What can be done to help older adults diagnosed with osteoarthritis that is increasingly exponentially to remain independent and active, an increasingly desirous state from many perspectives in the face of multiple health challenges and limited disease mitigation successes or recipes? While several standard approaches have been employed for some considerable time with some degree of success, a possible improvement in this regard may yet be realized by a focus on psychological disease correlates.

    In this regard increasing evidence appears to support a role for better stress control and intervention efforts to improve coping ability and confidence perceptions (eg., 12) and avert a cycle of decline both physical as well as psychological. As mentioned above, ample research shows the controllability of a chronic stressor such as osteoarthritis may well determine the prognosis and outcome of the disease, and the ongoing ability of the individual to function independently-as indicated. Even if surgery is required an older adult with a high degree of pain control may heal more optimally than a similar case that has poor pain control and confidence to manage successfully. They may also have less progressive joint damage than a similar patient who has not been involved proactively in mediating or moderating their health behaviors and thoughts as well as a possible lower degree of health care resource needs and costs of care, while averting a possible cascade of negative long term outcomes including a low quality of life 26515253.

    Romer 24 has revealed that the stressors associated with osteoarthritis involve physical, psychological, as well as social aspects of their lives. In particular, pain, disability and dependence on others were identified as major stressors. The majority of the respondents that were studied appraised the personal significance of having osteoarthritis as stressful both in terms of actual loss and potential loss in the future, and felt angry on occasion as a result as well as frustrated, discouraged, fearful and helpless. No differentiation was made between stress due to osteoarthritis and non osteoarthritis sources, but both may have been implicated, and could have been impacted to some degree via thoughts directed towards hope or some form of prayer 30.

    Although not yet a mainstream osteoarthritis treatment standard, increasing numbers of researchers point to the importance of an affected individual s active involvement in their self care, including the importance of dealing successfully and in a timely way with pervasive, transient, and future anticipated degrees of disability, pain and stresses 1754. Moreover, it appears the possible additive non disease based stresses of aging, along with pain and other health conditions, and life situations as regards the disease prognosis, implies a more insightful approach to offset or allay excess disability by considering the value of both behavioral and cognitive management approaches in addition to physically oriented care strategies 55 as the standard of care. Indeed, even if the benefits of careful mental health assessments are not at all mainstream or validated, they appear to be strongly advised for dealing with osteoarthritis associated pain and other symptom challenges 395657.

    This proposed integrated intervention process is arguably not a simple one however, and potentially requires dedicated time and careful long term guidance by a well informed health professional or team, rather than any singular reliance on generic stand alone or remotely delivered sets of customized directives. A considerable body of research indicated that what is especially needed in this regard are careful comprehensive evaluations including assessments of the patients beliefs, fears of movement and pain, plus beliefs about the origin and expected outcome of their disease.

    The provider s willingness to help clients to better understand their options, how stress might effect their joints adversely, for example excess stress might lead to eating behaviors that increase body mass markedly and adversely, while conveying the idea that contrasts possible benefits of actively attempting to cope and promote their wellbeing might reduce their pain and enhance their functional abilities. Additionally, patient education that addresses erroneous beliefs and misconceptions that prevail concerning osteoarthritis, especially the role of active movement as an osteoarthritis causative factor appears imperative to explore and understand 5658.

    Indeed, without adequate subjective as well as objective patient evaluations and assessments that do not overlook one or more cognitive disease correlates it may be impossible to provide targeted and precise help, such that the destructive osteoarthritis process may continue unabated, and prove overwhelming, and hazardous. For example, in the case of the circulation of unproven remedies or beliefs that surgery alone can restore function and eliminate pain but no other efforts are of possible help, even carefully construed management programs that are integrated suitably may be delivered too late in the disease cycle. In addition, communications that present an ageist portrayal of the older adult, or are not geared to the older versus younger adult, plus those that assume the older adult can duly grasp, interpret and act on medical information and can hence make sound decisions may well prove of more harm than good. At the same time, a combination of fatalism and inaction and/or erroneous beliefs and fears may preclude the emergence of a needed degree of affirmative mental toughness that has been observed to have a favorable bearing on orthopedic disease outcomes 59. To the contrary, efforts to reduce or mitigate stress, pain, and anxiety along with efforts to strengthen mental health toughness can be expected to enhance general self efficacy as well as coping confidence, plus the motivation to persevere with and adopt a set of regular health promoting self care practices 50. Indeed, evidence points to the paramount importance of efforts directed towards fostering pain and disease coping skills even if surgery is forthcoming at some point 50555960.

    However, even if sought, for example using artificial technology, no perfect mitigation recipe currently exists that can be duly delivered to advance management and delay regression of this complex disease where some older adults have no major problems but others may require considerable attention, especially if they appear unaware of their osteoarthritis management options, and have been using blunting: or avoidance strategies to manage their condition due to limited coping skills and confidence. A fair percent of cases may also have associated health problems such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or obesity, plus depression and disease severity 61 that must be factored in to any meaningful recommendation program to lower pervasive and transient day to day stressors and advance independence. On the other hand, those who receive due consideration may find they can progressively limit their pain levels proactively through one or more life affirming approaches than those who have given up hope or believe they need to rely on passive modalities and external support, or simply enter a state of denial or inaction blaming age alone for their condition. As such highly recommended are sound mutually motivated patient provider communications, along with emergent patient-centered or personalized tailored approaches 62, designed to affect perceptions of controllability of the disease and its oftentimes highly stressful overall health impact on daily life, sleep, social and cultural activities and work 58.

    While the most suitable methods of fostering adaptive coping may consequently differ considerably 34, those that involve problem solving and steps towards improving emotional regulation as indicated show considerable potential as a rule, as do interventions to reduce fear, pain exaggeration tendencies and diminishing aspects of general wellbeing 16636465 especially among those who report low perceptions of their pain coping ability 6364. Linking older adults with chronic illnesses such as osteoarthritis to others in the social network especially those with similar traits and problems who are motivated to succeed and have succeeded may also prove of considerable benefit 66.

    To further foster adaptive coping behaviors, a process of small doable steps and short range versus long term goal setting of doable actions is recommended so as to allow for the emergence of some tangible success, and motivation to pursue an increasing array of challenges including aging attributes 52646657. Exposure to role models, the receipt of needed resources, and opportunities to rehearse what is desirable in small progressive steps may further enable one or more adaptive coping behaviors to emerge 5267 as may efforts to foster integrated, collaborative, and culturally responsive care 58.

    Resnick 68 who conducted research to better understand the factors that can influence the efficacy beliefs of older adults as regards being motivated to participate in a rehabilitation program identified 11 major themes amenable to intervention. These included: motivation and verbal encouragement, having exposure to positive role models, being able to deal effectively with patient s past experiences, and current aversive physical sensations. Additional research has shown that for purposes of enhancing exercise adherence, a problem of major concern to all patients who suffer from pain, training the individual in pain reduction skills through relaxation, distraction or imagery, and repeating the demanding activity while applying the acquired pain reduction skills may prove successful. In addition, educating patients to better manage pain and cope with disease flares, helping them to understand why and how emotional reactions can affect their disease status as well as cellular aging may be of additional specific value. To enhance self efficacy for pain control, an important stress and osteoarthritis coping outcome mediator, the development of a carefully structured plan of achievable steps that can be practiced over time, along with efforts to minimize pervasive emotionally adverse thoughts, can possibly minimize the extent of pain and dysfunction that could otherwise emerge to impact life quality, all factors considered 6869707172.

    Keys to success may also include: 1) The ability of the affected individual to forge a sound and supportive client-therapist relationship that permits mutual inquiry and goal setting. 2) Encouraging activity goals that align with the etiology and pathogenesis of the disease as well as the individual s preferences and abilities, 3) Active treatment of persistent depression, 4) Mindfulness meditation, becoming better educated about the values and benefits of exercise, deep breathing, visual imagery, and being exposed to successful models.

    Affiliations:
    Affiliations: