Abstract
The coronavirus Covid-19 strain that emerged in December 2019, continues to produce a widespread and seemingly intractable negative impact on health and longevity in all parts of the world, especially, among older adults, and those with chronic health conditions.
The first aim of this review article was to examine, summarize, synthesize, and report on the research base concerning the possible use of vitamin-D supplementation for reducing both Covid-19 risk and severity, especially among older adults at high risk for Covid-19 infections. A second was to provide directives for researchers or professionals who work or are likely to work in this realm in the future.
All English language relevant publications detailing the possible efficacy of vitamin D as an intervention strategy for minimizing Covid-19 infection risk published in 2020 were systematically sought. Key words used were:
Collectively, these data reveal vitamin D is a powerful steroid like compound that is required by the body to help many life affirming physiological functions, including immune processes, but its deficiency may seriously impact the health status and well being of the older adult and others. Since vitamin D is not manufactured by the body directly, ensuring those who are deficient in vitamin D may prove a helpful overall preventive measure as well as a helpful treatment measure among older adults at high risk for severe Covid-19 disease outcomes.
Older individuals with chronic health conditions, as well as healthy older adults at risk for vitamin D deficiency are likely to benefit physically as well as mentally, from efforts to foster adequate vitamin D levels. Geriatric clinicians can expect this form of intervention to reduce infection severity in the presence of Covid-19 infection, regardless of health status, and subject to careful study, researchers can make a highly notable impact in this regard.
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2020
Marks Ray.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Introduction
The COVID-19 or pandemic remains an intractable problem despite months of study and investigation of the many possible causes, as well as strategies for amelioration or prevention. At the same time, adults with a variety of chronic health conditions may not be able to either access or receive optimal care due to many travel and other social restrictions. This narrative report focuses on vitamin D as a possible antidote to the widespread risk of severe illness on acquiring this virus, as well as for mediating its severity, and fostering a more rapid return to health. Since vitamin D may prove helpful for ameliorating or preventing Covid-19, and sunlight is one source of vitamin D that may be challenging to harness by many who are home bound or live in northern countries, or who are bound by a variety of cultural norms, work situations indoors or underground, or living in regions where the potency of ultraviolet light is diminished as a result of global warming, can a case be made for vitamin D supplementation among older at risk adults and others? Indeed, older adults, especially those who now have restrictions placed on their movements due to the Covid-19 pandemic may not only be highly vulnerable to the consequences of vitamin D deficiency, but may not understand the implications of their situation in this respect, even if they personally follow legal Covid-19 rulings in all respects. Discussed is the evidence base in favor of efforts to ensure all citizens, including older adults, and especially those with chronic health conditions associated with a deficiency of vitamin D, such as diabetes, one of four main disease correlates found among Covid-19 cases. Some information on the past use of vitamin D in other infectious diseases such as influenza is discussed as well. Drawn largely from the PUBMED database, the overview should provide the interested reader a general view of past work as well as current trends in this regard that might be worthy of further consideration and study, as well as applications in the health care field. Covid-19, which may occur independently as a separate health condition, or in conjunction with one or more chronic health conditions, may well be life threatening, and even if not, may induce the presence of other illnesses, while heightening prevailing adverse life events and functional losses, including immense life quality and socioeconomic losses. While the world waits for a possible Covid-19 antidote, other remedies to offset excess risk of Covid-19 and its consequences must be sought as argued by Simonson Although research in this realm is clearly in its infancy, and based largely on observational studies, Covid-19 infection and death rates do appear to be notably higher in the elderly than any other sub group, and this may be mediated in part, by the presence of a prevailing vitamin D deficiency. Since many adults suffer from this particular deficiency, it can be argued that a proportion of Covid-19 cases may be preventable. Since vitamin D sources are several, potential efforts to attain adequate sunlight exposure, exposure to foods or beverages containing vitamin D, and/or supplementation of vitamin D in vulnerable adults may be more beneficial than not. Indeed, if found to be influential in any way, intervention in this regard may provide one avenue that is reasonably practical for purposes of securing the well-being of the aging person, especially in the case of the chronically ill older adult that alone can heighten risk of infection due to its overall potentially debilitating effect on immune, musculoskeletal and cognitive health. Others may be given medications that render them more prone to Covid-19, and less likely to be ‘good’ surgical candidates or ventilator candidates if they have severe disabling chronic health conditions, especially those who may also be vitamin D deficient. This work is significant because the ability to minimize Covid-19 risk and severity is currently of the highest importance, especially among the elderly confined to their homes in isolation, as well as nursing homes, or to situations that limit sunlight and nutrient based vitamin D exposure. As discussed by Mok et al. This narrative review aimed to specifically examine the value of vitamin D therapy for or minimizing the risk of acquiring Covid-19 infections in the older population, especially those with preexisting vitamin D deficits. Its second aim was to offer recommendations for future consideration by clinicians and researchers in the field based on these findings.
Materials And Methods
To obtain the data for this review, the electronic data sources PUBMED, Scopus, and Web of Science were searched. The time period searched ranged from January 1 2020- December 2, 2020 and the key words included
Results
Of the more than 60,000 publications on Covid-19, published as of December 2 2020, a total of 307 articles potentially relevant to the current topic were listed on PUBMED To provide an overview of this quite considerable, but potentially highly relevant material in this regard, this review chose to discuss the science base and basis as regards vitamin D as a form of possible form of prevention and/or therapy relative to acute respiratory infections, such as Covid-19 among older adults. Findings regarding its specific immune related benefits and others relevant to the safely and life quality of the older adult are described. The term vitamin D is applied throughout, even though several formulae and categories of this compound exist. Past research onthe value ofvitamin D in the context of health status, shows this compound in its various forms has the potential to strongly influence overall health status and outcomes across the lifespan, including the elderly, as well as outcomes of infections analogous to the Covid-19 pandemic. While most of these data point to research on vitamin D deficits and how these may raise the risk of more severe infection responses in the vulnerable adult Among the 75 studies and reports retrieved from the present search, Merzon et al. Martineaus et al. Mok et al. As well, Laird et al. Ali et al. Radujkovic et al. According to Carpagnano et al. Similarly Brenner et al. As noted above, the reports documented in this review, which are largely current, stem predominantly from either hypothetical, analogous research in the realm of respiratory conditions, anecdotal or observational data, hence should be viewed with caution, despite their overall meaningful conclusions in the face of a pandemic that has produced few preventive pharmacologic based strategies or amelioration approaches that are readily accessible and cost-effective. Indeed, as per Grant et al. On the other hand, as proposed by Caccialanza et al. As well a careful review of allied past, as well as several existing studies (sampled in Abbreviations: ARD: Acute respiratory disease; Covid: Covid-19; grp: group; wks; weeks
Brenner et al.
9458 ARD cases
Prospective 15 yrs
Potentially protective
Baktash et al.
Older Covid-19 cases
Prospective
May predict outcomes
Carpagnano et al.
42 ARD cases
Retrospective
May predict mortality
Castillo et al.
76 hospitalized cases
Pilot randomized trial
Reduced Covid severity
D’Avolio et al. [21
Swiss patients
Retrospective
Correlates with Covid-19
Daneshkhah et al.
Covid-19 patients
Prospective
May predict severity
Merzon et al.
Members health grp
Observational
Covid-19 risk factor
Hastie et al.
Biobank cases
Retrospective
No Covid relationship
Ilie et al.
Published literature
Analytic
Suggests Covid-19 link
Kaufmann et al.
National lab data
Observational
Is Covid-19 related
Karahan et al.
149 Covid-19 patients
Retrospective
Vitamin D/severity linked
Maghbooli et al.
235 Covid cases
Observational
May impact Covid-19
Mardani et al.
65 male, 58 females
Prospective
May impact Covid-19
Munshi et al.
7 studies
Analytic
May be linked to Covid
Ohaegbulam et al.
4 cases low vitamin D
Case series
Supplements help
Panagiotou et al.
Cohort ill patients
Retrospective
Severe Covid linkage
Pizzini et al.
109 cases at 8 wks
Prospective
Low vitamin D-no effect
Radujkovic et al.
185 Covid-19 cases
Prospective
Impacts Covid outcome
Sabetta et al.
Healthy subjects
Prospective cohort
Lowers ARD risk
Discussion
Although modern medicine has previously been quite successful in managing infection rates globally, despite periodic epidemics, it is less successful in arresting rates of Covid-19 infections globally. While the world awaits an effective vaccine, as per Ebadi and Montano-Loza Moreover, cumulative evidence points not only to the impact of vitamin D on many genes with a well-established salience to airway infections, as well as immune processes At the same time, as outlined by Grant et al. On the other hand, knowing that high doses may pose a risk to an older adult, avoiding these excess doses pending further study seems wise as discussed by Lanham-New et al. One of 22 cited studies and listed as actively recruiting patients, proposes to test the efficacy of either daily high dose vitamin D supplementation (6000 IU vitamin D3/day) versus standard care. Those individuals ≥50 years of age or older who test positive for COVID-19 at baseline will be randomized to bolus vitamin D (20,000 IU/day for 3 days) followed by high dose (6000 IU vitamin D/day) vs. standard of care for 12 months. All participants will receive a multivitamin containing vitamin D-but the rationale for these doses and mode of application do not seem to parallel the daily recommended doses for an older population, such as that being studied, and may be detrimental and are not recommended In short, it appears low vitamin D levels, may adversely impact innate and adaptive immunity that can lead to Covid-19 infections and their severity and mortality However, to validate these ideas, as well as to solidify the data, and overcome conjecture, well-powered and carefully conceived clinical, as well as epidemiological and environmental research should be conducted Areas that could be fruitful to focus on in the future are: The correlates of prevailing health status, prescription medication usage, and/or cultural practices that may preclude adequate sunlight exposure. Air pollution and this possible Covid-19 correlate Other topics that might prove fruitful if examined more intently are Covid-19 associated inflammation, coagulopathy, reduced platelet count, and prolonged prothrombin time and other outcome correlates Moreover, since the vitamin D dosages that would possibly prove impactful among various older adults at risk for Covid-19 are not well established at all, more attention to this issue appears necessary. At the same time, greater efforts towards controlling for current medication and supplement usage, as well as sunlight in forthcoming studies is essential. In addition, a sizeable number of scholars point to the value of specifically examining the potentially influential role of gender, geography, health status, living arrangements, nutrient intake and access on intrinsic vitamin D availability levels and need in efforts to heighten immune function and reduce Covid-19 risk and fatalities
Conclusion
Covid-19 infections clearly remain immensely problematic to control and treat, especially among older adults, but could be impacted favourably by vitamin D supplements and intake, as indicated. Ascertaining whether this may help seems imperative even if a vaccine is forthcoming.