International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine

International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine

Current Issue Volume No: 1 Issue No: 3

Research-article Article Open Access
  • Available online freely Peer Reviewed
  • The Effects Of A 7-Minute HIIT Workout On Stress And Burnout In Outpatient Physical Therapists

    1 Lebanon Valley College, Annville, PA, USA 

    2 Marywood University, Scranton, PA, USA 

    Abstract

    Physical therapists (PTs) experience stress and burnout due to high job and productivity demands. Exercise can assist in decreasing stress and burnout, but finding the time to exercise can be difficult. This study examined the effects of a 28-day, 7-minute, high intensity interval training (HIIT) workout on PT s stress and burnout levels.

    In this quasi-experimental pretest-posttest design, the Perceived Stress Scale, Maslach Burnout Inventory, grip strength, Functional Reach Test, and VO2max measures were administered on day 1 and day 28. Between the data collection period, participants completed a daily, 7-minute HIIT workout. A series of paired sample t-tests were computed to compare the pre- and post-HIIT raw values.

    Significant improvements were found in all comparisons post-HIIT (p< .001). Therefore, it was concluded that 7-minutes of HIIT can assist PTs in reducing stress and burnout levels. Employers should consider implementing a workplace wellness program to benefit their employees.

    Author Contributions
    Received Nov 15, 2024     Accepted Dec 09, 2024     Published Dec 21, 2024

    Copyright© 2024 Salvo Charles, et al.
    License
    Creative Commons License   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

    Competing interests

    The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.

    Funding Interests:

    Citation:

    Salvo Charles, Kissling Kristin, Bearzi Andre, Bondarenko Victoria, Llanso Tate et al. (2024) The Effects Of A 7-Minute HIIT Workout On Stress And Burnout In Outpatient Physical Therapists International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. - 1(3):32-42
    DOI 10.14302/issn.2690-0904.ijoe-24-5353

    Introduction

    Introduction

    Stress in the workplace leads to poorer work outcomes.1 Additionally, physical and mental health conditions are associated with high levels of stress. Stress can cause a weakening of the immune system and deconditioning due to low levels of physical activity.2 Emotional stress in the workplace can also lead to burnout.3 Burnout is defined as a mental and physical symptom of chronic stress in the workplace and it can include depersonalization, emotional exhaustion, and low feelings of accomplishment.345

    It is important to understand the differences between burnout and stress in the literature. According to Pines and Kienan workplace burnout is related to a reduction in sense of significance at work, as well a reduction of meaning and importance of an individuals’ work. While stress can have a significant impact on this, not all work stressors are considered negative and leading to burnout. High negative stress levels are associated with occupational strain.6 Over a quarter of physical therapists report high emotional exhaustion, 15% report high stress, and 13% report experiencing burnout throughout their careers’.7 Burnout may also cause a lack of empathy among physical therapists which can lead to worse patient outcomes secondary to a decreased connection with their patients.4 Therefore, reducing burnout in physical therapists is crucial to improving patient outcomes.

    Wolff, et al. found a correlation between physical activity and mental health factors, which could help to improve burnout.9 Regular physical activity has been found to reduce stress levels, anxiety, and depression in the general population.2 Exercise has been shown to reduce adrenaline and cortisol and improve endorphin levels, which lowers an individual’s stress level.10 More recent studies looking at the physiology of exercise link the Sirtuin 1 (SIRT1) enzyme, which has been shown to be regulated by physical activity, to reducing physiological stress and improving antioxidant capacity and decreasing cardiovascular dysfunction.11 Specifically, physical therapists who engage in regular exercise are shown to have improved mental health and well-being, while those who perform less activity report higher stress levels.12 Even exercise that falls below recommended levels has been shown to improve physical and mental health in healthcare workers.13 Healthcare workers who engage in regular physical activity experience positive mental health outcomes such as reduced stress and anxiety.13

    Despite the benefits of exercise, it is difficult to allocate the time to improving fitness.14One solution for time efficiency is utilizing high-intensity interval training (HIIT) workouts.15 HIIT has been shown to improve aerobic capacity, body composition, strength and power in lower limbs,and functional independence in the general population.16 HIIT training also improved mental health in individuals, including reduced depressive symptoms and stress levels.17 Exercise bouts as short as six minutes have been shown to improve energy, motivation, and mental fatigue in the older adult population.18 The speed of the physical activity performed was crucial in showing mental health improvements indicating that short bouts of HIIT may be beneficial in improving mood in individuals.18

    Utilizing a 7-minute HIIT training program to reduce stress and burnout levels in physical therapy has not yet been directly researched. However, based on the present literature on exercise, HIIT training, and their relationship to mental health, performing a 7-minute HIIT training program is likely to improve stress and burnout levels among full-time physical therapists. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of a 28-day, 7-minute, HIIT workout on outpatient PT’s stress and burnout levels. The null hypothesis stated that a 7-minute HIIT workout does not improve PT’s stress and burnout levels.

    Results

    Results

    Participants were evaluated for stress using the PSS questionnaire and for burnout using the MBI questionnaire both pre and post study. PSS scores ranging from 0-13 were considered low perceived stress, score ranging from 14-26 are considered moderate perceived stress, and scores 27-40 are considered high perceived stress. Scores were calculated for each component of the MBI and used to determine whether the participant was indicating low-level, moderate, or high-level burnout for each category. No participant identified as being a high-level burnout in all three categories which is indicative of being at risk of burnout either pre- or post-study. Preliminary analysis was done for assumption testing prior to any group comparison. No missing values were found. In a few cases of Chi-square proportion comparison, some groups had less the five cases as indicated in Table 2.

    PSS Score and MBI Score Classification Comparison Pre- to Post- HIIT (N=31)
    Description Pre-HIIT N (%) Post-HIIT N (%) CHI-SQ
    Perceived Stress Scale Score     8.010 *
      Low 9 (29.0) 19 (61.3)  
      Moderate 22 (71.0) 12 (38.7)  
      High 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0)  
    MBI Score (Exhaustion)     1.431
      Low 18 (58.1) 30 (96.8)  
      Moderate 13 (41.9) 1 (3.2)  
      High 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0)  
    MBI Score (Depersonalization)     18.483 **
      Low 5 (16.1) 9 (29.0)  
      Moderate 13 (41.9) 15 (48.4)  
      High 13 (41.9) 7 (22.6)  
    MBI Score (Personal Achievement     13.670 *
      Low 11 (35.5) 18 (58.1)  
      Moderate 8 (25.8) 9 (29.0)  
      High 12 (38.7) 4 (12.9)  

    p < 0.01

    p < 0.001

    A series of paired sample t-tests were conducted to compare the pre- and post-HIIT raw values of participants’ PSS score and MBI scores. Preliminary analysis was done for assumption testing prior to any group comparison. No missing values were found. Normality was found in most groups via Shapiro-Wilk tests, with a few violations ignored due to the robustness of the t-tests uses. Significant differences were found in all comparisons with improvement seen for all scores post-HIIT as shown in Table 3.

    PSS, MBI, Dominant Hand Grip Strength, Non-dominant Hand Grip Strength, Functional Reach, and VO2 Max Raw Value Comparison Pre- to Post- HIIT (N=31)
    Description Pre-HIITM (sd) Post-HIITM (sd) t-value
    PSS Score 16.29 (5.48) 12.13 (5.53) 5.697 **
    MBI Scores      
    Exhaustion 14.77 (6.55) 9.48 (4.50) 6.519 **
    Depersonalization 11.74 (6.28) 8.00 (5.03) 4.218 **
    Personal Achievement 34.90 (8.25) 40.19 (5.83) -4.807 **
    Dominant Hand Grip Strength 49.16 (17.97) 53.65 (17.34) -3.459 *
    Non-dominant Hand Grip Strength 48.41 (16.65) 51.74 (16.78) -2.479 *
    Functional Reach 14.73 (1.70) 16.13 (2.20) -4.271 **
    VO2 Max 49.39 (10.30) 54.65 (11.42) -4.044 **

    p < 0.02

    p < 0.001

    A series of independent sample t-tests were conducted to compare the pre- and post-HIIT raw values of participants’ PSS score and MBI scores between individuals that reported being treated for stress and those not being treated for stress. Preliminary analysis was done for assumption testing prior to any group comparison. No missing values were found. Normality was found in most groups via Shapiro-Wilk tests, with a few violations ignored due to the robustness of the t-tests uses. Levene’s test for equality indicated equal variances (p > 0.05) between compared groups in all instances. No differences were found in any of the cases as shown in Table 4.

    PSS and MBI Raw Value Comparison of participants being treated for stress, pre- and post-HIIT (N=31)
    Description Treatment for Stress (N = 5) ReportedM (sd) No Treatment for Stress (N = 26) ReportedM (sd) t-value
    Pre-HIIT      
    PSS Score 17.00 (5.05) 16.15 (5.65) 0.311
    MBI Scores      
    Exhaustion 13.40 (5.41) 15.04 (6.80) -0.506
    Depersonalization 10.00 (5.96) 12.08 (6.40) -0.671
    Personal Achievement 36.00 (10.32) 34.69 (8.02) 0.320
    Pre-HIIT      
    PSS Score 13.20 (6.50) 11.92 (5.45) 0.467
    MBI Scores      
    Exhaustion 7.80 (2.78) 9.81 (4.73) -0.911
    Depersonalization 5.80 (2.95) 8.42 (5.27) -1.071
    Personal Achievement 42.00 (6.44) 39.85 (5.77) 0.751

    Discussion

    Discussion

    This study aimed to find a solution to prevent burnout syndrome and reduce negative stressors in physical therapists through a 7-minute HIIT workout for 4 weeks. From the primary analysis, physical therapists who completed the 7-minute HIIT workout demonstrated significant improvements in the PSS and MBI. Only 7 minutes of daily exercise produced significant improvements in not only mental health, but also balance, strength, and cardiovascular stamina. Incorporating a 7-minute HIIT exercise program will likely lead to improved job satisfaction and productivity. Rodriguez-Garcia, et al., found that physical therapists experiencing burnout demonstrate less empathy which may lead to worse patient outcomes due to a decreased connection with their patients.15 Physical therapists also may be able to provide higher quality care to their patients since they are less likely to experience emotional exhaustion.26 7 minutes of exercise is also beneficial for those therapists who work full-time jobs and have a family, as it decreases the time constraint needed to produce significant improvements in one s stress and burnout levels which can lead to a more positive work place environment, improved patient outcomes, and benefit the reputation of the business. Employers can use this data to incorporate a workplace wellness program to reduce employee healthcare costs, increase productivity, decrease work loss time, and provide a positive return on investment.

    Caparros-Manosalva, et al., and Rodriguez-Garcia, et al., also found that HIIT improves aerobic capacity, body composition, strength in lower limbs, power in lower limbs, and functional independence in the general population. Juan and colleagues noted that a single bout of HIIT can increase SIRT1 muscular gene expression while chronic exercise increases overall blood levels of SIRT1.11 These studies concur with these findings and reinforce that utilizing a 7-minute HIIT workout has the benefits of improving grip strength (dominant and non-dominant hands), balance, and VO2 max. Performing a short exercise bout can produce significant improvements in physical performance measures, similar to a traditional exercise program. Therefore, a 7-minute HIIT workout does not need to be done in addition to one s current exercise program and may still produce benefits similar to a traditional program. This form of workout may be beneficial for individuals with time constraints and may be having trouble finding time to perform any physical activity outside of work.

    There were identified limitations to this study. This study utilized convenience sampling which may not reflect the proper results of the entire population of physical therapists. There are often larger than regional differences in stress levels which may not have been accounted for. In collecting our measurements there were some slight inconsistencies with the testing surfaces for the 3 Minute Step Test. In some instances, a high-low table was used and set to the proper height and in other instances, steps that could be stacked on top of each other were used to conduct the test. This subtle change in the surface may have an impact on results. In addition, all participants were aware of the goals of the study prior to participating, which may have skewed their self-reported stress scores into being higher than they truly were post-intervention. Other confounding variables may include other exercises programs subjects may have been participating in, additional outside life stressors not related to the clinic, sickness, and the pre- and post-tests being completed before and after daylight savings which may have altered mood.

    While previous studies examined the effects of exercise on mental health, stress, and burnout, this study is believed to be the first to explore the effects of high intensity interval training on stress and burnout in physical therapists. Despite this study yielding significant results in all measured outcomes, the sample size of 31 participants limits the generalizability of the results. Additionally, all participants were exposed to the independent variable (HIIT workout), raising the question as to whether improvements can be attributed specifically to high intensity interval training rather than general exercise. It is recommended that future studies including larger sample sizes as well as a control variable be completed to either support or refute the findings of this study that high intensity interval training can decrease stress and burnout in physical therapists. Furthermore, to increase the accuracy and validity of our data some future suggestions include being able to monitor daily workouts our subjects completed on the app Seven, utilizing cardiovascular measurements to make sure participants were working at high enough intensities during their HIIT workouts each day, and standardizing the risers used for the 3-minute step test.

    Conclusion

    Conclusion

    Based on the current findings of this study, it can be concluded that in as little of a time commitment of 7 minutes daily, Physical therapists can benefit from a high intensity interval training workout to reduce stress and career burnout, improve VO2 max, increase their functional reach ability, and improve grip strength. Employers can utilize these findings in implementing a workplace wellness program to reduce employee healthcare costs, increase productivity, and decrease work loss time.

    Affiliations:
    Affiliations: