International Journal of Coronaviruses

International Journal of Coronaviruses

Current Issue Volume No: 2 Issue No: 4

Research-article Article Open Access
  • Available online freely Peer Reviewed
  • Chirps Amidst Coronavirus Disease-2019 (COVID-19) Transmission And Prevention In Ethiopia In 2020

    Assegid Sahilu 1
       

    1 MD, MPH, Associate Professor of Epidemiology Jimma University, Jimma, Ethiopia 

    Abstract

    Background

    Ethiopia confirmed its 1st case of COVID-19 on Friday 13th February 2020. The burden increased dramatically by August/2020. The conditions that led to this rise were not reviewed.

    Objective

    To exploreCOVID-19 related phenomena in Ethiopia during 2019-2020.

    Materials and Methods

    Review of journals, books, and letters to editors, e-sources, news, personal experiences, observations, and communications.

    Results

    The zoonotic source of SARS- CoV-2 (Severe Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome- Coronavirus-2) is not confirmed. The precedent events; and exact mechanism of COVID-19 is not clear. Dynamic models were required on the time line of dynamics of COVID-19; dynamics of infectiousness of COVID-19, and mechanism of transmission of COVID-19. Incubatory carriers might have been missed. Screening based on temperature had been problematic. The time spent in the development of diagnostic test for COVID-19 might have contributed to the early spread.

    Uninterrupted flights to China during the epidemic by Ethiopian Airlines as well as uninterrupted domestic flights; IDP (Internally Displaced People); and others put Ethiopia (and other countries) at great risk. Demographic adjustment may not be applicable for Ethiopia due to lack of census which had to be conducted every 10 year, was conducted only in 2007. This adds to the problem of error projection. The impact of HIV (Human Immuno-Deficiency Virus Disease) and war in Ethiopia before 2000 might have had affected people who would be now old age and who would be at the most risk of death. This made the impact of COVID-19 to appear low as revealed by the lower number of COVID-related deaths in Ethiopia. There were also hesitations inconsistencies in case definitions; implementations of quarantine; and burial regulations.

    Conclusion

    Even though uninhibited foreign flight to China as well as domestic flights; inconsistencies in the implementation of regulations pertaining to COVID-19 have contributed to COVID- 19 emergence in Ethiopia, the absence of census; the demographic impact of HIV and war before 2000 might have made the impact of COVID-19 to appear low as revealed by the lower number of COVID-related deaths in Ethiopia.

    Recommendation

    Accurate and current evaluation of the impact of COVID-19 in Ethiopia may require the absence of census; demographic consequences of HIV; and war before 2000 into consideration.

    Author Contributions
    Received Feb 10, 2021     Accepted Mar 18, 2021     Published Apr 03, 2021

    Copyright© 2021 Assegid Sahilu.
    License
    Creative Commons License   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

    Competing interests

    The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

    Funding Interests:

    Citation:

    Assegid Sahilu (2021) Chirps Amidst Coronavirus Disease-2019 (COVID-19) Transmission And Prevention In Ethiopia In 2020 International Journal of Coronaviruses. - 2(4):45-53
    DOI 10.14302/issn.2692-1537.ijcv-21-3741

    Introduction

    Introduction

    The famous Chinese philosophe Confucius wisely advised “Study the past if you would divine the future”. 1

    In 430 B.C. a great plague struck Athens and its great leader was killed. The Athenians sought guidance from the Oracle at Delos who said that the god Apollo was angry and if his cubical altar was doubled in size the plaque would be abolished. The Athenians built a new altar doubling the width, height, and depth. The plague worsened so they went to the Oracle and found that Apollo wanted the volume doubled whereas the Athenians had octupled it. The plague continued until 423 B.C. 2 to control a rat infestation, colonial rulers in Hanoi in the 19th century passed a law: for every dead rat handed in to the authorities, the catcher would receive a reward. When it was realized that the infestation worsened, they ordered its investigation. The investigators reported that many rats were destroyed, but many were also bred specially for this purpose. 3, pp. 18)

    Coronavirus disease-2019 (COVID-19) emerged in early December 4 or identified in late December in Wuhan, and WHO (World Health Organization) declared COVID-2019 a Public Health Emergency of International Concern on Thursday, 30 January 2020, and the number of cases imported into other countries increased, and the epidemiological map was changing rapidly. 5 According to preprint of April 2020, COVID-19 has been spreading rapidly across the world, and was recognized as a pandemic by the WHO and on March 11 2020. 6

    Results

    Results and Discussion

    By April 15/2020 the zoonotic source of SARS- CoV- 2 had not been confirmed, however, the sequence-based analysis suggested bats as the main reservoir. 7 A publication on April 09, 2020, the theory behind our healthcare model has been refuted with the COVID-19 pandemic which also implies lasting changes in that new medical model. 10 The theory about the genesis of COVID-19 and bat to man transmission had not been substantiated.

    An article published online April 20/2020 “… Optimal mitigation policies might reduce peak healthcare demand by 2/3 and deaths by half. And resulted in hundreds of thousands of deaths …. Drastic revision of R0 was called for. 11 The virulence or death/cases had been underestimated. Definition of R0 had undermined non-contact e.g. direct projection, or indirect transmission.

    But, instead of focusing on which model is correct, we should accept that “one model cannot answer it all” and that we need more models that answer complementary sub questions that can piece together the jigsaw and halt COVID- 19 spread. 11 There can be methodology that can be applied to any form of model, e.g. the expansion method in diffusion studies- model that does not presuppose invariance of model parameters

    As of April 17, 2020, across the 10 countries with most COVID-19 deaths the total number of infected to be approximately 4, 95%CI 210 times the number of confirmed cases. 12 in short the ratio covert/overt cases or concealed/revealed, or 1/pathogenicity had been were underestimated.

    April 2020 recommendations said that future studies addressing the diagnostic performance of tests for COVID-19 in the Brazilian population were urgently needed. 14. A letter to the editor published online March 9/2020 stated ‘currently, RT-PCR is a reliable test’ in detecting both symptomatic and asymptomatic COVID-19. 5 As to asymptomatic detection only occurs if patients are followed up proactively from the time of exposure. 15

    Screening and testing depend on, among others, timing, type of test, site from where specimen was taken, symptoms. Also the time spent in the development of diagnostic/screening test for COVID-19 might have contributed to the early spread.

    Body temperature screening may miss travelers incubating the disease or travelers concealing fever during travel. 5 Incubatory carriers might have been missed. Screening based on body temperature, and the time spent development of non-contact measurement of body temperature might have added to the problem of early detection.

    It will not be morally acceptable to stop flying to China today because they’ve a temporary problem. 21 Even though the Ethiopian Airline planes evolved into cargos, early in the pandemic COVID-appeared a temporary problem.

    Different sources gave different information on the onset of COVID-in Ethiopia, for instance Ethiopia confirmed its 1st case of COVID-19 on Friday 13th February 2020. 18 The 1st COVID-19 case in Ethiopia was detected and reported on March 13, 2020. 19 Ethiopia, with about 107 million people, confirmed its 1st case of COVID-19 on March 13. 20

    Nevertheless, between COVID-2019 emergence in December 2019 in Wuhan, 2 and the time of the WHO’s declaration COVID-2019 a Public Health Emergency of International Concern on Thursday, 30 January 2020, 5 the Ethiopian Airlines might already have had several flights to China. The Ethiopian government was said to have displayed remarkable reluctance to curtail its Ethiopian Airlines flights and an executive said “It will not be morally acceptable to stop flying to China today because they’ve a temporary problem.”  17 Furthermore on June 19 2020 the Ethiopian official on Friday called for boosting China-Africa solidarity in fighting against the COVID-19 pandemic. 22 These issues together with others put Ethiopia- and other countries at great risk.

    Although on June 18, Ethiopia appreciated China for “successfully curbing the spread of the COVID-19 disease and for its unyielding support to Ethiopia's fight against the scourge." 22 This shows people have no good advisees. The flights were scourge. In earlier time of the pandemic, concerned with the continued flight, the BBC Africa focus had interviewed the same foreign minister he said the health system can cope it.Rather the impact of HIV and war in Ethiopia before 2000 might have had affected the would be now old age which is COVID-19’s stronghold, making COVID-19’s impact upon Ethiopia lower as revealed by the number of deaths, which is the most fraught outcome, lower.

    On 19 June, the Government eased quarantine regulations by announcing that “all travelers arriving at Bole International Airport in Addis Ababa carrying a certificate of negative PCR SARS-CoV-2 test, done up to 72 hours before arrival, will be able to follow the 14-day quarantine at home after giving sample upon arrival. 23 Certificate is no guarantee about the future.

    Travelers and returnees with no certificate of negative PCR SARS-CoV-2 test results will be quarantined for 7 days in the designated sites, tested, and then able to self-isolate for additional 7 days at home.” 23 This statement is elusive. In the month of June 2020, the radio broadcast of one region announced in Amharic that all returnees (likely this is related to movements via borders), who arrived to that region during the previous 2 months had to report in personally to the regional office.

    Government’s movement restrictions related to COVID-19 have been eased allowing inter-regional movements throughout the country. 23 There were deep rooted problems with ethnic federalism.

    Although it was reported that Ethiopia had about 107 million people, 20 and, an article in April said that, as many countries lack population based sero- prevalence studies, straightforward demographic adjustment can be used to deliver useful estimates of the total number of infected cases, 12 Demographic adjustment and may not be applicable for Ethiopia due to reluctance on census which had to be conducted every 10 year was conducted only in 2007. This adds to the problem of error projection. Also it has to be noted that COVID-19 was not responsible for all deaths during the previous 9 months of 2020.

    Conclusion

    Conclusions

    The genesis/bat to man transmission had not been confirmed. The precedent events; and exact mechanism of COVID-19 is not clear.

    Dynamic models and mechanism of transmission of COVID-19 were not complete

    The time spent in the development of diagnostic test for COVID-19 might have contributed to the early spread.

    Incubatory carriers might have been missed. Screening based on temperature had been problematic

    Uninterrupted International; domestic flights and IDP during 2020 had put Ethiopia- and other countries at great risk.

    Demographic adjustment may not be applicable for Ethiopia due to lack of census which had to be conducted every 10 year was conducted only in 2007 adds to the problem of error projection. The impact of HIV and war in Ethiopia before 2000 might have had affected those who would be now in old age were they to survive, and who would be at most risk of COVID-19 related deaths. COVID-19’s impact on Ethiopia as revealed by the number of deaths appeared lower for possibly for these conditions.

    Affiliations:
    Affiliations: